[YUNIKORN-575] Skip creating placeholders for the completed apps post restart

• Type: Sub-task
• Status: Closed
• Priority: Major
• Resolution: Fixed
• Affects Version/s: 0.10
• Fix Version/s: 0.10
• Component/s: shim - kubernetes
• Labels: pull-request-available
• Assignee: Weiwei Yang Assign to me
• Reporter: Ayub Pathan
• Created: 16/Mar/21 04:41
• Updated: 21/Jan/22 21:48
• Resolved: 16/Mar/21 20:16

Description

• Post restart, YK tries to recover the completed apps and schedules placeholder pods(even though the real pods are in completed state), which may not be needed. This leads to resource mismanagement.

  gang-app-timeout-1006-5jqqk               0/1     Completed   0          69m
  gang-app-timeout-1007-tw44t               0/1     Completed   0          66m
  gang-app-timeout-1008-dmzc4               0/1     Completed   0          64m
  gang-app-timeout-1008-dwxgq               0/1     Completed   0          64m
  gang-app-timeout-1008-sl2x9               0/1     Completed   0          64m
  tg-timeout-1006-gang-app-timeout-1006-0   1/1     Running     0          60s
  tg-timeout-1006-gang-app-timeout-1006-1   1/1     Running     0          60s
  tg-timeout-1006-gang-app-timeout-1006-2   1/1     Running     0          60s
  tg-timeout-1007-gang-app-timeout-1007-0   1/1     Running     0          60s
  tg-timeout-1007-gang-app-timeout-1007-1   1/1     Running     0          60s
  tg-timeout-1007-gang-app-timeout-1007-2   0/1     Pending     0          60s
  tg-timeout-1008-gang-app-timeout-1008-0   1/1     Running     0          60s
  tg-timeout-1008-gang-app-timeout-1008-1   1/1     Running     0          60s
  tg-timeout-1008-gang-app-timeout-1008-2   1/1     Running     0          60s
  

• All the completed apps are marked as failed, post restart and the allocations are not released. This could be a resource leak post restart.

  [
      {
          "allocations": null,
          "applicationID": "gang-app-timeout-1009",
          "applicationState": "Accepted",
          "partition": "[mycluster]default",
          "queueName": "root.fifo",
          "submissionTime": 1615868052062417676,
          "usedResource": "[]"
      },
      {
          "allocations": null,
          "applicationID": "gang-app-timeout-1011",
          "applicationState": "Accepted",
          "partition": "[mycluster]default",
          "queueName": "root.fifo",
          "submissionTime": 1615868052062788287,
          "usedResource": "[]"
      },
      {
          "allocations": null,
          "applicationID": "gang-app-timeout-1010",
          "applicationState": "Accepted",
          "partition": "[mycluster]default",
          "queueName": "root.fifo",
          "submissionTime": 1615868052057156621,
          "usedResource": "[]"
      },
      {
          "allocations": null,
          "applicationID": "gang-app-timeout-1003",
          "applicationState": "Accepted",
          "partition": "[mycluster]default",
          "queueName": "root.fifo",
          "submissionTime": 1615868052062023562,
          "usedResource": "[]"
      },
      {
          "allocations": [
              {
                  "allocationKey": "0a761a05-4b00-4e34-a54d-22411007553a",
                  "allocationTags": {
                      "kubernetes.io/label/applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1008",
                      "kubernetes.io/label/queue": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/namespace": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/podName": "tg-timeout-1008-gang-app-timeout-1008-0"
                  },
                  "applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1008",
                  "nodeId": "ip-10-192-131-213.ca-central-1.compute.internal",
                  "partition": "default",
                  "priority": "0",
                  "queueName": "root.fifo",
                  "resource": "[memory:300 vcore:300]",
                  "uuid": "9704811c-422d-4efa-bb42-ab565fb5f16b"
              },
              {
                  "allocationKey": "2505258b-3358-4143-b2a2-9084ffa0977b",
                  "allocationTags": {
                      "kubernetes.io/label/applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1008",
                      "kubernetes.io/label/queue": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/namespace": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/podName": "tg-timeout-1008-gang-app-timeout-1008-1"
                  },
                  "applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1008",
                  "nodeId": "ip-10-192-131-213.ca-central-1.compute.internal",
                  "partition": "default",
                  "priority": "0",
                  "queueName": "root.fifo",
                  "resource": "[memory:300 vcore:300]",
                  "uuid": "e0ff467d-ec18-4d5b-b981-861835f1604a"
              },
              {
                  "allocationKey": "29dbfaec-7632-4bff-b4ea-e313521497f1",
                  "allocationTags": {
                      "kubernetes.io/label/applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1008",
                      "kubernetes.io/label/queue": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/namespace": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/podName": "tg-timeout-1008-gang-app-timeout-1008-2"
                  },
                  "applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1008",
                  "nodeId": "ip-10-192-142-84.ca-central-1.compute.internal",
                  "partition": "default",
                  "priority": "0",
                  "queueName": "root.fifo",
                  "resource": "[memory:300 vcore:300]",
                  "uuid": "6723d3ac-c7c8-4935-bb23-3b443909a252"
              }
          ],
          "applicationID": "gang-app-timeout-1008",
          "applicationState": "Failed",
          "partition": "[mycluster]default",
          "queueName": "root.fifo",
          "submissionTime": 1615868050004448061,
          "usedResource": "[]"
      },
      {
          "allocations": [
              {
                  "allocationKey": "05d87d17-a6dc-4bc0-b495-c76f1cd0a3cb",
                  "allocationTags": {
                      "kubernetes.io/label/applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1007",
                      "kubernetes.io/label/queue": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/namespace": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/podName": "tg-timeout-1007-gang-app-timeout-1007-0"
                  },
                  "applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1007",
                  "nodeId": "ip-10-192-131-213.ca-central-1.compute.internal",
                  "partition": "default",
                  "priority": "0",
                  "queueName": "root.fifo",
                  "resource": "[memory:300 vcore:300]",
                  "uuid": "67401008-61b0-4957-8361-6d0e8917c21f"
              },
              {
                  "allocationKey": "1af95692-0186-44fe-b712-30edb51b85c2",
                  "allocationTags": {
                      "kubernetes.io/label/applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1007",
                      "kubernetes.io/label/queue": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/namespace": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/podName": "tg-timeout-1007-gang-app-timeout-1007-1"
                  },
                  "applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1007",
                  "nodeId": "ip-10-192-142-84.ca-central-1.compute.internal",
                  "partition": "default",
                  "priority": "0",
                  "queueName": "root.fifo",
                  "resource": "[memory:300 vcore:300]",
                  "uuid": "5d1f129e-3e40-4103-b2e6-53daf408465f"
              }
          ],
          "applicationID": "gang-app-timeout-1007",
          "applicationState": "Failed",
          "partition": "[mycluster]default",
          "queueName": "root.fifo",
          "submissionTime": 1615868050004840460,
          "usedResource": "[]"
      },
      {
          "allocations": [
              {
                  "allocationKey": "8524d2ab-a591-4fca-8a5f-3847e8d173ab",
                  "allocationTags": {
                      "kubernetes.io/label/applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1006",
                      "kubernetes.io/label/queue": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/namespace": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/podName": "tg-timeout-1006-gang-app-timeout-1006-1"
                  },
                  "applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1006",
                  "nodeId": "ip-10-192-142-84.ca-central-1.compute.internal",
                  "partition": "default",
                  "priority": "0",
                  "queueName": "root.fifo",
                  "resource": "[memory:300 vcore:300]",
                  "uuid": "909735f0-607b-4799-bf4c-8b45f59c174b"
              },
              {
                  "allocationKey": "b33078a1-aac6-4217-afd5-3c80248782dd",
                  "allocationTags": {
                      "kubernetes.io/label/applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1006",
                      "kubernetes.io/label/queue": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/namespace": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/podName": "tg-timeout-1006-gang-app-timeout-1006-2"
                  },
                  "applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1006",
                  "nodeId": "ip-10-192-131-213.ca-central-1.compute.internal",
                  "partition": "default",
                  "priority": "0",
                  "queueName": "root.fifo",
                  "resource": "[memory:300 vcore:300]",
                  "uuid": "80f04647-ada2-4851-9361-d6bcb5c18c65"
              },
              {
                  "allocationKey": "e7aa1b09-fac8-43bf-aae9-48215086ae36",
                  "allocationTags": {
                      "kubernetes.io/label/applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1006",
                      "kubernetes.io/label/queue": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/namespace": "fifo",
                      "kubernetes.io/meta/podName": "tg-timeout-1006-gang-app-timeout-1006-0"
                  },
                  "applicationId": "gang-app-timeout-1006",
                  "nodeId": "ip-10-192-142-84.ca-central-1.compute.internal",
                  "partition": "default",
                  "priority": "0",
                  "queueName": "root.fifo",
                  "resource": "[memory:300 vcore:300]",
                  "uuid": "f6172318-7e4a-4252-8bf5-8346de4a4d48"
              }
          ],
          "applicationID": "gang-app-timeout-1006",
          "applicationState": "Failed",
          "partition": "[mycluster]default",
          "queueName": "root.fifo",
          "submissionTime": 1615868050003595376,
          "usedResource": "[]"
      }
  ]
  

YK UI snapshot showing apps marked as failed.

Attached log. yk_recover.log

Issue Links

• links to: GitHub Pull Request #241