Uploaded image for project: 'Solr'
  1. Solr
  2. SOLR-3383

Async responses in SolrJ




      Today it is like this

      • SolrServer.request returns NamedList<Object>
      • SolrRequest.process returns SolrResponse
      • Public methods on SolrServer like addX, optimize, commit, queryX etc. returns subclasses of SolrResponse (e.g. "add" returns UpdateResponse)
      • etc

      This is all synchronous - that is, the calling thread of those methods will wait for the response before being able to continue. I believe the industry today agrees that "operations" like client-server network-requireing operations should be done asynchronously seens from the client API. Therefore basically we should change those methods

      • SolrServer.request returns Future<NamedList<Object>>
      • SolrRequest.process returns Future<SolrResponse>
      • SolrServer.xxx returns Future<subclass of SolrResponse>
        and make the appropriate changes in the implementations below.

      My main argument for this right now, is that ConcurrentUpdateSolrServer really is not able to hand over responses to the calling client. Guess that it is also the reason why it is only a "Update"SolrServer and not a complete SolrServer (being able to do queries etc.) - updates does not require sending responses (except primitive errors) back to the client, queries etc does. Now that we do "finegrained error propagation" (SOLR-3382) in order to send "unique key constraint" and "versioning"-errors (SOLR-3173 and SOLR-3178) back to the client in responses to update-request, suddenly it is not true anymore that updates does not require sending responses back to the client.
      Making the changes suggested above (returning Futures) would

      • Allow ConcurrentUpdateSolrServer to be used for updates potentially resulting in "unique key constraint"- and "versioning"-errors
      • Allow ConcurrentUpdateSolrServer to become ConcurrentSolrServer - also being able to do queries etc
      • Do cool stuff like SOLR-3384
      • Make SolrJ more modern with respect to asynchronous principles


        1. SOLR-3383.patch
          331 kB
          Per Steffensen

        Issue Links



              steff1193 Per Steffensen
              steff1193 Per Steffensen
              7 Vote for this issue
              14 Start watching this issue