Uploaded image for project: 'Hadoop HDFS'
  1. Hadoop HDFS
  2. HDFS-10716

In Balancer, the target task should be removed when its size < 0.



    • Reviewed


      In HDFS-10602, we found a failing case that the balancer moves data always between 2 DNs. And it made the balancer can't be finished. I debug the code for this, I found there seems a bug in choosing pending blocks in Dispatcher.Source.chooseNextMove.

      The codes:

          private PendingMove chooseNextMove() {
            for (Iterator<Task> i = tasks.iterator(); i.hasNext();) {
              final Task task = i.next();
              final DDatanode target = task.target.getDDatanode();
              final PendingMove pendingBlock = new PendingMove(this, task.target);
              if (target.addPendingBlock(pendingBlock)) {
                // target is not busy, so do a tentative block allocation
                if (pendingBlock.chooseBlockAndProxy()) {
                  long blockSize = pendingBlock.reportedBlock.getNumBytes(this);
                  task.size -= blockSize;
                  // If the size of bytes that need to be moved was first reduced to less than 0
                  // it should also be removed.
                  if (task.size == 0) {
                  return pendingBlock;

      The value of task.size was assigned in Balancer#matchSourceWithTargetToMove

          long size = Math.min(source.availableSizeToMove(), target.availableSizeToMove());
          final Task task = new Task(target, size);

      This value was depended on the source and target node, and this value will not always can be reduced to 0 in choosing pending blocks. And then, it will still move the data to the target node even if the size of bytes that needed to move has been already reduced less than 0. And finally it will make the data imbalance again in cluster, then it leads the next balancer.

      We can opitimize for this as this title mentioned, I think this can speed the balancer.

      Can see the logs for failling case, or see the HDFS-10602.(Concentrating on the change record for the scheduled size of target node. That's my added info for debug, like this).

      2016-08-01 16:51:57,492 [pool-51-thread-1] INFO  balancer.Dispatcher (Dispatcher.java:chooseNextMove(799)) - TargetNode: 58794, bytes scheduled to move, after: -67, before: 33


        1. HDFS-10716.001.patch
          0.8 kB
          Yiqun Lin
        2. failing.log
          49 kB
          Yiqun Lin

        Issue Links



              linyiqun Yiqun Lin
              linyiqun Yiqun Lin
              0 Vote for this issue
              6 Start watching this issue