Uploaded image for project: 'Apache Drill'
  1. Apache Drill
  2. DRILL-5808

Reduce memory allocator strictness for "managed" operators



    • Type: Improvement
    • Status: Resolved
    • Priority: Major
    • Resolution: Fixed
    • Affects Version/s: 1.11.0
    • Fix Version/s: 1.12.0
    • Component/s: None


      Drill 1.11 and 1.12 introduce new "managed" versions of the sort and hash agg that enforce memory limits, spilling to disk when necessary.

      Drill's internal memory system is very "lumpy" and unpredictable. The operators have no control over the incoming batch size; an overly large batch can cause the operator to exceed its memory limit before it has a chance to do any work.

      Vector allocations grow in power-of-two sizes. Adding a single record can double the memory allocated to a vector.

      Drill has no metadata, so operators cannot predict the size of VarChar columns nor the cardinality of arrays. The "Record Batch Sizer" tries to extract this information on each batch, but it works with averages, and specific column patterns can still throw off the memory calculations. (For example, having a series of very wide columns for A-M and very narrow columns for N-Z will cause a moderate average. But, once sorted, the A-M rows, and batches, will be much larger than expected, causing out-of-memory errors.)

      At present, if an operator is wrong in its memory usage by a single byte, the entire query is killed. That is, the user pays the death penalty (of queries) for poor design decisions within Drill. This leads to a less-than-optimal user experience.

      The proposal here is to make the memory allocator less strict for "managed" operators.

      First, we recognize that the managed operators do attempt to control memory and, if designed well, will, on average hit their targets.

      Second, we recognize that, due to the lumpiness issues above, any single operator may exceed, or be under, the configured maximum memory.

      Given this, the proposal here is:

      1. An operator identifies itself as managed to the memory allocator.
      2. In managed mode, the allocator has soft limits. It emits a warning to the log when the limit is exceeded.
      3. For safety, in managed mode, the allocator enforces a hard limit larger than the configured limit.

      The enforcement limit might be:

      • For memory sizes < 100MB, up to 2x the configured limit.
      • For larger memory sizes, no more than 100MB over the configured limit.

      The exact numbers can be made configurable.

      Now, during testing, scripts should look for over-memory warnings. Each should be fixed as we fix OOM issues today. But, during production, user queries are far less likely to fail due to any remaining corner cases that throw off the memory calculations.

      drill.memory.lenient.allocator - new system property (note: not option) should be documented.


          Issue Links



              • Assignee:
                Paul.Rogers Paul Rogers
                Paul.Rogers Paul Rogers
                Arina Ielchiieva
              • Votes:
                0 Vote for this issue
                3 Start watching this issue


                • Created:

                  Time Tracking

                  Original Estimate - 24h
                  Remaining Estimate - 24h
                  Time Spent - Not Specified
                  Not Specified