Details
-
Bug
-
Status: Closed
-
Major
-
Resolution: Not A Problem
-
1.1.1
-
None
-
None
Description
The problem is reading the spec we don't know if BeanManager can be injected through method parameter in producer/observer so it should probably be done.
here an extract of an IRC conversation with more details:
<rmannibucau> hi, is it possible to inject the bean manager in a method (like beforebeandiscovery) ?
<bergmark> Specifically a lifecycle method, or a method in a CDI manager bean?
<bergmark> I ask because you can certainly inject method params into methods in a managed bean. I don't think you can add a bean manager param to your afterBeanDiscovery event listener, but I might be wrong.
<bergmark> Spec seems to prove me wrong though 
<bergmark> 11.5 says that service providers can obtain an injected BeanManager
<bergmark> Presumably as a field though, not as a parameter into the observer method.
<rmannibucau> ah
<rmannibucau> i ask because seams does it
<rmannibucau> so it doesnt work with oprnwebbeans just because of it
<bergmark> seam injects the BeanManager as a parameter of the method with @Observes?
<rmannibucau> yep
<rmannibucau> in solder-impl-3.1.0.Beta3
<bergmark> Might be a bug then, its not clear to me what 11.5 means when it says "and obtain an injected BeanManager reference". That isn't very clear about how.
<bergmark> I just assumed it meant via an injected field in the service provider, but perhaps they intended that statment to apply to observer method injection as well inside service providers.