• Improvement
    • Status: Open
    • Major
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • None
    • 4.9, 6.0
    • modules/grouping
    • New


      Similar to SOLR-2526, in that you are grouping on 2 separate fields, but instead of treating those fields as a single grouping by a compound key, this change would let you first group on key1 for the primary groups and then secondarily on key2 within the primary groups.

      Ie, the result you get back would have groups A, B, C (grouped by key1) but then the documents within group A would be grouped by key 2.

      I think this will be important for apps whose documents are the product of denormalizing, ie where the Lucene document is really a sub-document of a different identifier field. Borrowing an example from LUCENE-3097, you have doctors but each doctor may have multiple offices (addresses) where they practice and so you index doctor X address as your lucene documents. In this case, your "identifier" field (that which "counts" for facets, and should be "grouped" for presentation) is doctorid. When you offer users search over this index, you'd likely want to 1) group by distance (ie, < 0.1 miles, < 0.2 miles, etc., as a function query), but 2) also group by doctorid, ie cascaded grouping.

      I suspect this would be easier to implement than it sounds: the per-group collector used by the 2nd pass grouping collector for key1's grouping just needs to be another grouping collector. Spookily, though, that collection would also have to be 2-pass, so it could get tricky since grouping is sort of recursing on itself.... once we have LUCENE-3112, though, that should enable efficient single pass grouping by the identifier (doctorid).




            Unassigned Unassigned
            mikemccand Michael McCandless
            0 Vote for this issue
            5 Start watching this issue