Details

      Issue Links

        Activity

        Hide
        andreaturli Andrea Turli added a comment -

        I think I was wrong, Token object contains details related to the catalog and endpoints so it is fine

        Show
        andreaturli Andrea Turli added a comment - I think I was wrong, Token object contains details related to the catalog and endpoints so it is fine
        Hide
        andreaturli Andrea Turli added a comment -

        I had a look at the keystone v3, they are quite richer than v2 and lots of new things there

        in particular, in v3 token mgmt needs to be a bit different as the response payload doesn't contain the token id (it is stored on a header)
        Also the "token" payload doesn't contain the services/endpoints as Access returned by https://developer.openstack.org/api-ref/identity/v2/index.html#authenticate so I think we need to use https://developer.openstack.org/api-ref/identity/v3/index.html#service-catalog-and-endpoints

        Anyone has an idea of what privileges I need to invoke /v3/endpoints as I get 403 Forbidden with my account?

        Show
        andreaturli Andrea Turli added a comment - I had a look at the keystone v3, they are quite richer than v2 and lots of new things there in particular, in v3 token mgmt needs to be a bit different as the response payload doesn't contain the token id (it is stored on a header) Also the "token" payload doesn't contain the services/endpoints as Access returned by https://developer.openstack.org/api-ref/identity/v2/index.html#authenticate so I think we need to use https://developer.openstack.org/api-ref/identity/v3/index.html#service-catalog-and-endpoints Anyone has an idea of what privileges I need to invoke /v3/endpoints as I get 403 Forbidden with my account?
        Hide
        gaul Andrew Gaul added a comment -

        jclouds is community-developed software and thus this feature will be implemented when a volunteer contributes it. Would you like to volunteer?

        Show
        gaul Andrew Gaul added a comment - jclouds is community-developed software and thus this feature will be implemented when a volunteer contributes it. Would you like to volunteer?
        Hide
        munishwork Munish Chaudhary added a comment -

        can anyone give an update on this issue. Any tentative date for its resolution ?

        Show
        munishwork Munish Chaudhary added a comment - can anyone give an update on this issue. Any tentative date for its resolution ?
        Hide
        everett-toews Everett Toews added a comment -

        Apologies but I won't be able to help out here.

        Show
        everett-toews Everett Toews added a comment - Apologies but I won't be able to help out here.
        Hide
        andreaturli Andrea Turli added a comment -

        hi Zack Shoylev, Everett Toews,

        I think supporting Openstack Keystone v3 is becoming really urgent as v2 is deprecated.

        Happy to help here, but do you guys know if there are openstack experts like you guys that can help here as well?

        Thanks

        Show
        andreaturli Andrea Turli added a comment - hi Zack Shoylev , Everett Toews , I think supporting Openstack Keystone v3 is becoming really urgent as v2 is deprecated. Happy to help here, but do you guys know if there are openstack experts like you guys that can help here as well? Thanks
        Hide
        nacx Ignasi Barrera added a comment -

        There is no date yet. I have to study the best way to implement it, but my intention is to make it transparent for users and let jclouds pick the right version of keystone based on the apiVersion field that can be configured when creating the context.

        Show
        nacx Ignasi Barrera added a comment - There is no date yet. I have to study the best way to implement it, but my intention is to make it transparent for users and let jclouds pick the right version of keystone based on the apiVersion field that can be configured when creating the context.
        Hide
        siddsr Siddarth Rai added a comment -

        Thanks a lot.
        Is there a tentative date though? Will it be a big change ?

        Show
        siddsr Siddarth Rai added a comment - Thanks a lot. Is there a tentative date though? Will it be a big change ?
        Hide
        nacx Ignasi Barrera added a comment -

        This is in mi high priority list, but I haven't been able to commit time to this yet. There are a lot of changes going on in Azure ARM that unfortunately go first in the queue, but I expect to start working on this issue as soon as we're done with Azure ARM (we're almost there).

        Show
        nacx Ignasi Barrera added a comment - This is in mi high priority list, but I haven't been able to commit time to this yet. There are a lot of changes going on in Azure ARM that unfortunately go first in the queue, but I expect to start working on this issue as soon as we're done with Azure ARM (we're almost there).
        Hide
        siddsr Siddarth Rai added a comment -

        Is there any update on this? Keystone v3 Support is almost mandatory now. Please let me know if there is any progress or if any one can give any pointers we can try it from our end.

        Show
        siddsr Siddarth Rai added a comment - Is there any update on this? Keystone v3 Support is almost mandatory now. Please let me know if there is any progress or if any one can give any pointers we can try it from our end.
        Hide
        apps.desh Apoorva added a comment -

        As per Keystone community, API v2 will be removed in Q release. At this point Pike is under development. If v3 is not supported then jclouds may be unusable with OpenStack beginning next release.

        Show
        apps.desh Apoorva added a comment - As per Keystone community, API v2 will be removed in Q release. At this point Pike is under development. If v3 is not supported then jclouds may be unusable with OpenStack beginning next release.
        Hide
        ykuo@mvista.com Yufen Kuo added a comment - - edited

        With OpenStack Mitaka release keystone deprecated all v2.0 APIs. The keystone team recommends using v3 APIs instead.
        Please re-consider to support Keystone v3 API. thanks!

        Show
        ykuo@mvista.com Yufen Kuo added a comment - - edited With OpenStack Mitaka release keystone deprecated all v2.0 APIs. The keystone team recommends using v3 APIs instead. Please re-consider to support Keystone v3 API. thanks!
        Hide
        dhague Darren Hague added a comment -

        I did start, but unfortunately got bogged down in the complexity of the jclouds code and ultimately we ended up using openstack4j instead.

        Show
        dhague Darren Hague added a comment - I did start, but unfortunately got bogged down in the complexity of the jclouds code and ultimately we ended up using openstack4j instead.
        Hide
        j.utzig Johannes Utzig added a comment -

        Have you started worked on this issue? I am also very interested in this feature and would be willing to help if I can.

        Show
        j.utzig Johannes Utzig added a comment - Have you started worked on this issue? I am also very interested in this feature and would be willing to help if I can.
        Hide
        dhague Darren Hague added a comment -

        I'd like to start working on this - could someone assign me to the ticket so I can mark it as "In progress"?

        Thanks,
        Darren

        Show
        dhague Darren Hague added a comment - I'd like to start working on this - could someone assign me to the ticket so I can mark it as "In progress"? Thanks, Darren
        Hide
        hnandela Haritha Nandela added a comment -

        Please update on the progress of this task.Is there timeline published for the 1.7 release ?

        Show
        hnandela Haritha Nandela added a comment - Please update on the progress of this task.Is there timeline published for the 1.7 release ?

          People

          • Assignee:
            nacx Ignasi Barrera
            Reporter:
            jdaggett Jeremy Daggett
          • Votes:
            17 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            19 Start watching this issue

            Dates

            • Created:
              Updated:

              Development