Uploaded image for project: 'Infrastructure'
  1. Infrastructure
  2. INFRA-12624

Missing archiver/archives for dev@incubator - is it needed?

    Details

    • Type: Bug
    • Status: Waiting for user
    • Priority: Major
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • Fix Version/s: None
    • Labels:
      None

      Description

      The dev@incubator mailing list is still active and has 6 messages:

      dev Digest of: get.1_6

      Topics (messages 1 through 6)

      HashPartitioner, strange behavior
              1 by: Erik Thorson
              2 by: Erik Thorson

      [ANNOUNCE] CFP open for ApacheCon North America 2016
              3 by: Rich Bowen

      FOSDEM 2016 - take action by 4th of December 2015
              4 by: Roman Shaposhnik

      Re: Spawning an Apache Geode Summit - March 9 2016 in Palo Alto, CA
              5 by: Greg Chase

      ApacheCon Seville CFP closes September 9th
              6 by: Rich Bowen

      However there does not appear to be an ASF archive for it, and the one on lists.apache.org only contains the latest message [1]

      It should probably be shut down.

      If not, then the archiver needs to be set up.
      Also the missing messages should be retrieved if possible.
      It looks like dev-get recovers the message bodies, but not the headers.

        Activity

        Hide
        sebb@apache.org Sebb added a comment - Reporter
        There's a similar problem with commits@incubator.
        There's no ASF mail-archive, but there are messages in lists.a.o dating back to May (all seem to be spam)
        It looks like lists.a.o was subscribed in May, but there were no archives that could be imported.
        Show
        sebb@apache.org Sebb added a comment - Reporter There's a similar problem with commits@incubator . There's no ASF mail-archive, but there are messages in lists.a.o dating back to May (all seem to be spam) It looks like lists.a.o was subscribed in May, but there were no archives that could be imported.
        Hide
        sebb@apache.org Sebb added a comment - Reporter
        It's possible that commits@ was intended/is defined as a catchall for incubator commits. In which case the archiver needs to be set up and previous messages recovered. However there is already a cvs@incubator mailing list.
        Show
        sebb@apache.org Sebb added a comment - Reporter It's possible that commits@ was intended/is defined as a catchall for incubator commits. In which case the archiver needs to be set up and previous messages recovered. However there is already a cvs@incubator mailing list.
        Hide
        sebb@apache.org Sebb added a comment - Reporter
        Below is the index.
        It looks as though it was used for some SVN commits.
        As far as I can tell it's not referenced in asf-mailer.conf (though that file is very tricky to parse visually)
        Maybe the commits@incubator exclusion was not present initially?

        1: svn commit: r1413490 - /incubator/streams/site/
                26 Nov 2012 pctony.apache.org
        2: svn commit: r1413602 - in /incubator/onami/trunk/logging: commons-logging/pom.xml juli/pom.xml log4j/pom.xml slf4j/pom.xml testframework/pom.xml
                26 Nov 2012 simonetripodi.apache.org
        3: +49 22302519960
                26 May 2016 Kopierer.incubator.apache.org
        4: Scanned image from copier@incubator.apache.org
                20 Jul 2016 copier.
        5: Scanned image from MX2310U@incubator.apache.org
                1 Sep 2016 office.incubator.apache.org
        6: Copy
                6 Sep 2016 Marissa yount
        Show
        sebb@apache.org Sebb added a comment - Reporter Below is the index. It looks as though it was used for some SVN commits. As far as I can tell it's not referenced in asf-mailer.conf (though that file is very tricky to parse visually) Maybe the commits@incubator exclusion was not present initially? 1: svn commit: r1413490 - /incubator/streams/site/         26 Nov 2012 pctony.apache.org 2: svn commit: r1413602 - in /incubator/onami/trunk/logging: commons-logging/pom.xml juli/pom.xml log4j/pom.xml slf4j/pom.xml testframework/pom.xml         26 Nov 2012 simonetripodi.apache.org 3: +49 22302519960         26 May 2016 Kopierer.incubator.apache.org 4: Scanned image from copier@incubator.apache.org         20 Jul 2016 copier. 5: Scanned image from MX2310U@incubator.apache.org         1 Sep 2016 office.incubator.apache.org 6: Copy         6 Sep 2016 Marissa yount
        Hide
        sebb@apache.org Sebb added a comment - Reporter
        The commits@incubator mailing list was actually used recently, and the dev@incubator was set as the reply-to so I think it does make sense to archive them.

        This needs the following lines added to .archives:

            "incubator-dev", "/home/apmail/public-arch/incubator.apache.org/dev/",
            "incubator-commits", "/home/apmail/public-arch/incubator.apache.org/commits/",

        Show
        sebb@apache.org Sebb added a comment - Reporter The commits@incubator mailing list was actually used recently, and the dev@incubator was set as the reply-to so I think it does make sense to archive them. This needs the following lines added to .archives:     "incubator-dev", "/home/apmail/public-arch/incubator.apache.org/dev/",     "incubator-commits", "/home/apmail/public-arch/incubator.apache.org/commits/",
        Hide
        johndament John D. Ament added a comment -
        [~sebb@apache.org] can you bring this up on the incubator mailing lists so we have visibility and can weigh in? We should ask infra to act once its decided what to do.

        For reference, its my opinion that we should just drop both, and maybe alias commits@incubator to cvs@incubator.
        Show
        johndament John D. Ament added a comment - [~ sebb@apache.org ] can you bring this up on the incubator mailing lists so we have visibility and can weigh in? We should ask infra to act once its decided what to do. For reference, its my opinion that we should just drop both, and maybe alias commits@incubator to cvs@incubator .
        Hide
        sebb@apache.org Sebb added a comment - Reporter
        Sorry, I don't have time to follow the incubator lists at present so I don't think it makes sense for me to raise the issue.
        Show
        sebb@apache.org Sebb added a comment - Reporter Sorry, I don't have time to follow the incubator lists at present so I don't think it makes sense for me to raise the issue.
        Hide
        humbedooh Daniel Gruno added a comment -
        transitioning to WFU til we have a response
        Show
        humbedooh Daniel Gruno added a comment - transitioning to WFU til we have a response
        Hide
        humbedooh Daniel Gruno added a comment -
        derp
        Show
        humbedooh Daniel Gruno added a comment - derp
        Hide
        ipv6guru Gavin added a comment -
        [~johndament] any news on this ?

        I agree we should just shut them down imho
        Show
        ipv6guru Gavin added a comment - [~johndament] any news on this ? I agree we should just shut them down imho
        Hide
        cml Chris Lambertus added a comment -
        Ping [~johndament]
        Show
        cml Chris Lambertus added a comment - Ping [~johndament]

          People

          • Assignee:
            Unassigned
            Reporter:
            sebb@apache.org Sebb
            Request participants:
            None
          • Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

            Dates

            • Created:
              Updated: