Uploaded image for project: 'Hive'
  1. Hive
  2. HIVE-20882 Support Hive replication to a target cluster with hive.strict.managed.tables enabled.
  3. HIVE-20968

Support conversion of managed to external where location set was not owned by hive



    • Sub-task
    • Status: Resolved
    • Major
    • Resolution: Won't Fix
    • 4.0.0
    • None
    • repl


      As per migration rule, if a location is outside the default managed table directory and the location is not owned by "hive" user, then it should be converted to external table after upgrade.
      So, the same rule is applicable for Hive replication where the data of source managed table is residing outside the default warehouse directory and is not owned by "hive" user.
      During this conversion, the path should be preserved in target as well so that failover works seamlessly.

      1. If the table location is out side hive warehouse and is not owned by hive, then the table at target will be converted to external table. But the location can not be retained , it will be retained relative to hive external warehouse directory. 
      2.  As the table is not an external table at source, only those data which are added using events will be replicated.
      3. The ownership of the location will be stored in the create table event and will be used to compare it with strict.managed.tables.migration.owner to decide if the flag in replication scope can be set. This flag is used to convert the managed table to external table at target.

      Some of the scenarios needs to be blocked if the database is set for replication from a cluster with non strict managed table setting to strict managed table.

      1. Block alter table / partition set location for database with source of replication set for managed tables
      2. If user manually changes the ownership of the location, hive replication may go to a non recoverable state.
      3. Block add partition if the location ownership is different than table location for managed tables.
      4. User needs to set strict.managed.tables.migration.owner along with dump command (default to hive user). This value will be used during dump to decide the ownership which will be used during load to decide the table type. The location owner information can be stored in the events during create table. The flag can be stored in replication spec. Check other such configs used in upgrade tool.
      5. Block conversion from managed to external and vice versa. Pass some flag in upgrade flow to allow this conversion during upgrade flow.


        1. HIVE-20968.01.patch
          85 kB
          mahesh kumar behera
        2. HIVE-20968.02.patch
          123 kB
          Sankar Hariappan
        3. HIVE-20968.03.patch
          156 kB
          Sankar Hariappan
        4. HIVE-20968.04.patch
          143 kB
          Sankar Hariappan
        5. HIVE-20968.05.patch
          145 kB
          Sankar Hariappan



            maheshk114 mahesh kumar behera
            maheshk114 mahesh kumar behera
            0 Vote for this issue
            2 Start watching this issue



              Time Tracking

                Original Estimate - Not Specified
                Not Specified
                Remaining Estimate - 0h
                Time Spent - 2h 50m
                2h 50m