Uploaded image for project: 'HBase'
  1. HBase
  2. HBASE-8365

Duplicated ZK notifications cause Master abort (or other unknown issues)



    • Bug
    • Status: Closed
    • Major
    • Resolution: Abandoned
    • 0.94.6
    • None
    • None
    • None


      The duplicated ZK notifications should happen in trunk as well. Since the way we handle ZK notifications is different in trunk, we don't see the issue there. I'll explain later.

      The issue is causing TestMetaReaderEditor.testRetrying flaky with error message

      reader: count=2, t=null

      A related link is at https://builds.apache.org/job/HBase-0.94/941/testReport/junit/org.apache.hadoop.hbase.catalog/TestMetaReaderEditor/testRetrying/

      The test case failure is due to an IllegalStateException and master is aborted so the rest test cases also failed after testRetrying.

      Below are steps why the issue is happening(region fa0e7a5590feb69bd065fbc99c228b36 is in interests):

      1) Got first notification event RS_ZK_REGION_FAILED_OPEN at 2013-04-04 17:39:01,197

       DEBUG [pool-1-thread-1-EventThread] master.AssignmentManager(744): Handling transition=RS_ZK_REGION_FAILED_OPEN, server=janus.apache.org,42093,1365097126155, region=fa0e7a5590feb69bd065fbc99c228b36

      In the step, AM tries to open the region on another RS in a separate thread

      2) Got second notification event RS_ZK_REGION_FAILED_OPEN at 2013-04-04 17:39:01,200

      DEBUG [pool-1-thread-1-EventThread] master.AssignmentManager(744): Handling transition=RS_ZK_REGION_FAILED_OPEN, server=janus.apache.org,42093,1365097126155, region=fa0e7a5590feb69bd065fbc99c228b36

      3) Later got opening notification event result from the step 1 at 2013-04-04 17:39:01,288

       DEBUG [pool-1-thread-1-EventThread] master.AssignmentManager(744): Handling transition=RS_ZK_REGION_OPENING, server=janus.apache.org,54833,1365097126175, region=fa0e7a5590feb69bd065fbc99c228b36

      Step 2 ClosedRegionHandler throws IllegalStateException because "Cannot transit it to OFFLINE"(state is in opening from notification 3) and abort Master. This could happen in 0.94 because we handle notifications using executorService which opens the door to handle events out of order through receive them in order of updates.

      I've confirmed that we don't have duplicated AM listeners and both events triggered by same ZK data of exact same version. The issue can be reproduced once by running testRetrying test case 20 times in a loop.

      There are several issues for the failure:

      1) duplicated ZK notifications. Since ZK watcher is one time trigger, the duplicated notification should not happen from the same data of the same version in the first place

      2) ZooKeeper watcher handling is wrong in both 0.94 and trunk as following:
      a) 0.94 handle notifications in async way which may lead to handle notifications out of order of the events happened
      b) In trunk, we handle ZK notifications synchronously which slows down other components such as SSH, LogSplitting etc. because we have a single notification queue
      c) In trunk & 0.94, we could use stale event data because we have a long listener list. ZK node state could have changed at the time when handling the event. If a listener needs to act upon latest state, it should re-fetch the data to verify if the data triggered the handler hasn't changed.

      For 0.94, we can bandit the CloseRegionHandler to pass in the expected ZK data version to skip event handling on stale data with min impact.

      For trunk, I'll open an improvement JIRA on ZK notification handling to provide more parallelism to handle unrelated notifications.

      For the duplicated ZK notifications, we need bring some ZK experters to take a look at this.

      Please let me know what you think or any better idea.


        1. TestResult.txt
          891 kB
          Jeffrey Zhong
        2. TestZookeeper.txt
          990 kB



            Unassigned Unassigned
            jeffreyz Jeffrey Zhong
            0 Vote for this issue
            8 Start watching this issue